Monday, May 19, 2025

Megadungeons

Got an Arcane Library newsletter in my inbox this morning. It was a Q&A of sorts. Found this small gem buried within it.

1. I've always wanted to make a megadungeon based on the layout of a mega mall. Could you write some thoughts on dos and don'ts with copying existing architecture for dungeon maps?

Definitely! Existing architecture is a great place to get ideas for room shapes and how areas flow together. It's also handy to note how buildings are structured around major rooms, like temples or grand halls.

However, one thing to be cautious of is having your layout be too symmetrical or utilitarian. Dungeons are supposed to be mythical places that don't always make sense. In fact, it's that surprising and unpredictable factor of a dungeon's layout that makes it fun to explore!

If a dungeon is too symmetrical, it will be too predictable as far as a game board goes. You want to make your mega mall a bit surreal, a bit nonsensical -- something that would never receive an actual building permit. You could keep some realism by making your mega mall look like it was added to several times throughout the decades, placing things in a decidedly "non-ideal" layout.

Wow. I actually didn't even emphasize the "as far as a game board goes" line; she did that herself. At the risk of sounding like a snowflake Millennial, I "can't even" with the OSR playstyle anymore. If D&D (or ShadowDark) is a board game, then yeah, we're not even talking about the same hobby that I recognize. While I admit to seeing a fair number of smug trad folks writing articles, columns, reviews and more in the 80s with their dismissal of the dungeon as a passe, childish fad who's time had come, that overzealousness faded quickly. While I often talk about one of the two mottos of 3e, "tools, not rules" the other motto was "back to the dungeon" and people have been playing that way for a long time now. In fact, if anything, truly trad play is somewhat on the outs; we have a lot of hybrid trad dungeon play, at least in the D&D and D&D-like games sphere. The official WotC campaigns, and Paizo adventure paths all strike this pose. The only truly trad stuff that I regularly see is in other games, like WFRP or Call of Cthulhu. (Although I'm sure there's plenty more out there in other games that I'm not as familiar with.)

Maybe I'm making a false distinction between trad and "hybrid trad." What I really should say, probably, is that my rejection of dungeoneering in favor of more natural types of game play that resemble 1) almost every other non-D&D or D&D-like game, and 2) almost every story in the source material that D&D is supposedly based on (and every other type of story too, for that matter) is, curiously, a somewhat radical stance, apparently. Or at least it seems to be true that few people play that way, and maybe ever have. Maybe my time outside of D&D for pretty much all of the 90s has given me a skewed view of what the RPG hobby is and how most people engage with it. One so skewed that the 25 years since hasn't completely purged me of RPG.net think. Maybe.

Before I finished typing up this post, I found this newly posted video by Professor Dungeon Master that seems to talk, albeit in somewhat different language, about the great playstyle divide, and it's longevity. It's an interesting addition to what I said, I think, and should be watched as a different take (with similar conclusions, however) on the same concept.



Coverup is worse than you thought

https://open.substack.com/pub/coffeeandcovid/p/oil-spill-monday-may-19-2025-c-and?r=21uqse

As Childers says, prostate cancer doesn't just come out of nowhere. Either one of two things is happening:

1) The cancer risk caused by the vaxx is much worse than even the worst expectations, and turbo-cancers coming from nowhere that are suddenly terminal is a thing. I'm aware of some circumstantial, anecdotal evidence that will support the linked study in the article above, so I wouldn't be surprised.

2) More likely, they all knew he had cancer already, and not only did they cover-up his cognitive decline, but they also covered up his cancer. Harris was always the plan A after all, but they didn't want to have to show that because of her extreme unlikability. They thought that they could maintain the implausible narrative that Biden actually won—twice—and then have totter off and die like the President in Dave while the real "president" Harris, who was always as much of a bubble-headed figurehead as Biden, but potentially a little bit less obvious, could step in.

As the Z-man says, "The data in this case was our eyes. Everyone not blinded by their own models of reality saw a frail, doddering old man. Management’s model, however, showed that he was a model of fitness and virility. Now that model is being revised to show he was actually suffering from dementia and has aggressive cancer. The new model is now converging with reality." It's indicative of the crisis that managerialism has with reality in general.

Sunday, May 18, 2025

Larry Elmore and Wayne Reynolds

I'd like to buy some Larry Elmore prints and frame them for when I have a study/library/office in our more permanent house. When we sell our house up north and buy one here, which may not be for a little while, because our son and his family are living in it currently. But when I do...

In the meantime, I can go much cheaper and print these Wayne Reynolds images at Walmart, which I extracted from various Paizo pdfs, and frame them, if I want to. I can just stick them in cheap store-bought picture frames rather than art frames. It's a temporary measure, but it'll work for a few years, if it takes that long. And they may be cool in their own right. Trying to decide which ones I want. Here's the potential options, with some commentary.

I really like the concept of a ghost dragon, but as is often the case, especially in the Paizo images, it's the characters that I'm a bit more hesitant on. This collection isn't the worst, but it's also not the best.

This one is probably one of the best options I've got.

This one isn't Paizo; it's Green Ronin's Black Sails Over Freeport module cover. It's a bit more lower fantasy, which is one of the things that I prefer about it.

Love the dragon. Don't really like the characters, especially the "Persian" lesbian sun cleric.

This also isn't Paizo. I think this was posted on ENWorld years ago, but it's a WotC image. 

Probably another keeper, like the black dragon one. I like that it especially focuses on the fighter, and the weird sorceress girl is slightly backstaged.

Same two characters as above, plus that weird goblin bomber. I could do without him. And I'd have preferred the wizard from the black dragon painting to the sorceress girl, but Paizo is determined to DEI up most of their images with a bunch of action-grrls. At least this one is white. There's this one sheboon character that they really like who never looks good in any image, because she's this butch paladin type.


Saturday, May 17, 2025

Some more Hero Forge

I've done my Gaskarfells dark pseudomages, which my son-in-law pointed out looks quite a bit like Harry Dresden, even though I was actually imitating the necromancers from Scarred Lands Hollowfaust. But here's a few other Hero Forge items I've done lately. 

I feel like I'm no longer on the cutting edge of Hero Forge. I'm still not great at kitbashing, and I'm just getting started with body customizer. But, hey, you gotta start somewhere!



These three angles of a plague doctor "alchemist" were largely based on something Professor Dungeon Master did with his Reviled Society campaign report. He had some other plague doctor minis, but I decided to make my own criminal alchemists and this is what I came up with. Three different angles, but same mini.

I call this guy Abdul Alhazred, but he was originally based on the Darkest Dungeon Occultist. Made him even more creepy and weird and I'll call him a scary sorcerer well on his way towards corruption and insanity. Appopriate, though, since the Occultist was clearly based on Alhazred to begin with...

This was another take on the Darkest Dungeon bounty hunter, but with an eye towards not necessarily being faithful to the original so much as utilizing the new (at the time) chain mail.

I dunno; just a guy I was messing around with. Looks like a Tarushan or maybe even Terassan thief.

I was never happy with Little Beatriz, so I thought I'd start over from scratch now that I could use body customizer to shrink the hands to a realistic size. The feet still seem big, but I didn't really get the hair that I wanted. And, at the end of the day, I don't feel like my choices for her dress were quite what I wanted either. Also; I just looked at the date for that Little Beatriz post; I can't believe I came up with that in 2011. Time is really flying...

Speaking of Hollowfaust, I didn't like it as much as I remember liking it on re-reading it (which I did on my recent trip to Mexico.) I still like the main idea, but I think Eberron did it better with Karrnath. I also read the second Black Raven (of two) collected semi-linked episodic stories by Seth Skorkowsky. I'm kinda disappointed. While mostly relatively well written, there are a few things that consistently bug me:

  • There's some kind of fantasy race (I think; possibly it's just a human ethnicity) called quellen, and they appear a lot. But he never describes them, or if he did, it was early on in the first book, and he never revisits the description. I have no idea what they are or what they're supposed to look like, which is a major oversight and kind of distracting when I keep reading about quellen characters.
  • The Black Raven himself kind of has a dumb nickname. What other color would a raven be, and why would a supposed top tier criminal leave a distinctive calling card? At least it wasn't that he left the water running...
  • For a supposed top tier criminal, we rarely see him actually being all that competent. Most of his jobs go sideways, because he just happens to bump into someone while stealing whatever.
  • He's also super beta, and the girl that he seems to really like is... I guess an exciting kind of character for a gamma dude, but isn't very likeable to anyone else.
  • Speaking of, his relationship with his mafia-esque organization is pretty beta too. Maybe I'm spoiled with Conan and Tarzan type stories, about men who take charge of their own destiny and don't take flak from anyone. 
  • In all, after reading the entirety of Sea of Quills, I started to find the main character and his shenanigans kind of cringy. Granted, I've read pretty much all of them now; and if a new Black Raven book came out, I doubt I'd even notice (I stopped following Seth's YouTube channel a few months ago. He was kind of on the fence for me anyway, because his content isn't enough of what I want, and his presentation is kind of cringy, but when he replaced his twitter contact info on the channel with gaysky contact info, I knew I couldn't do it anymore with him.) So I will almost certainly have no idea if he produces more Black Raven content. But if it does... I think I've had enough of it anyway.

A triton duelist

Thursday, May 15, 2025

Represent

I've had this shirt, plus a blue one with the expert art, for months now and I wear it regularly. But for whatever reason just in the last week or so I've had no less than four strangers approach me to comment positively on it. Three of them just in the last 24 hours curiously. Two of them were reasonably attractive younger women, which was even more surprising. I mean, young enough to be my kids (who range from 21-29 at the moment). The others were older Gen x guys. 

I don't know. I find that fact oddly... satisfying.


UPDATE: Up to five. The stewardess doing the safety demo just have me a wink and thumbs up after pointing at my shirt. But then she came up later thinking that I looked really familiar. Odd as it may be because she was a good twenty years younger than me, maybe she was just flirting with me.

UPDATE: Two more young guys freaked out over it. What a crazy weekend for this shirt! 

UPDATE: Here's my Expert shirt. At one point, I wanted to get a Companion and Master shirt too, but I couldn't find a Companion shirt that had the right color teal to represent the box. Plus, I never really played BECMI anyway. I played some LBBs, some B/X and some Holmes before we started adopting AD&D. Then I skipped ahead to 3e after leaving D&D alone for a time.



Saturday, May 10, 2025

Gaskarfells pseudomage necromancer

Improved the Hero Forge image a bit and took some more shots of it. Thank goodness for the flexibility that body customizer and kitbashing allows. I'm not a great Hero Forge artist by any means, but I can still get cool results.





Thursday, May 08, 2025

Gaskarfells

Every once in a while, I need to step back and take stock of where I am. Quick context aside:

  • When 4e was new, WotC announced the book Open Grave focused on Undead. (I still haven't read it, but I believe I have a pdf. I think.) In the product announcement, they talked about the idea of a kingdom ruled by vampires. Without knowing anything at all on how they would develop this idea, me and an online colleague tinkered with the idea, bantered about some concepts, and I ended up with my own creation, Tarush Noptii, my vampire kingdom.
  • When I did the Cult of Undeath project, adapting Paizo's Carrion Crown adventure path to something I could use, I ended up coming up with an abbreviated alternative to Ustalav, the fantasy HorrorLand part of the Golarion theme park that had obvious call-backs to a romanticized Transylvania. This became, after a few trial names that didn't work, Timischburg.
  • Because Tarush Noptii had more high concept and Timischburg had more details, I decided to combine the two. Tarush Noptii became the prior name of the place, when the Tarushans ran it. After the Coming of the Timischers, it was renamed, and most of the aristocracy are now Timischers, who resemble Hapsburg Austrians. The Tarushans resemble fantasy Romanians and/or Hungarians and/or Balkan Slavs.
  • Now that Cult of Undeath is getting reworked again, I'm doing significantly different things with it, but I retain my desire to utilize the Timischburg and Tarush Noptii "assets", and I'm changing somewhat what the "plot points" are of the campaign, as well as some of the geography. I'd originally had a whole column of the 5x5 take place in Vyrko Lodge, which was based on one of the old Carrion Crown adventures. This has changed significantly, but I still need the concept of a town in the forest surrounded by foresty threats and dangers. After casting around for names, I ended up—just today, in fact—with Gaskarfells.

But I don't want Gaskarfells to be just a lodge in the forest. I want it to be a unique and unusual and flavorful town. So I turned to some other older material to see if they had some concepts or ideas that I could adapt. I picked up a book that I haven't read in over twenty years, Hollowfaust: City of Necromancers and while it has a lot of ideas that I won't be using because they're way too D&Dish, or way to embedded with the Scarred Lands setting in which they take place, the kernel of the idea is right there. Eberron seems to have borrowed this same idea as pragmatic, not-necessarily-evil necromancers as a key element of their Karrnath kingdom too, although they, again, did it quite differently. 

When Tarush, the "Dark God" (who created the Primeval Vampires of Tarush Noptii out of the very champions who journeyed to where he fell from the sky to seal him away in what is now the capital city of Grozavest) fell to the earth, he brought with him a trail of cosmic detritus. One of the things that fell to the earth was a meteorite of some cosmic ore, a green, glowing rock that brings with it an affinity towards sorcerous power and ruin (as all sorcery eventually does.) This rock, superheated by its landing in the Bitterwood, created a large crater, knocked down trees for miles (like Tunguska) and lay upon the ground in vast pools and bubbling fragments in a molten state. As such, it seeped into the existing bedrock, and fused with the rock, forming the material called fellshard ore. This isn't unique; it has fallen from other meteorites and fused with other rocks in various places throughout the Three Realms and more, but the Bitterwood was the place where the largest concentration of it fell, so far known, anyway, and the quantity here is both quite potent and relatively plentiful. Over the years, the forest regrew around the crater, although flash-petrified fallen trees still linger on the ground, with newer growth—now centuries old—coming up around them. The sorcerous corruption of the purer meteoric material is the source of the name Bitterwood; causing mutations, pollution and more in the forest... but once it fused and merged with the bedrock, the corruption was stabilized and no longer had a deleterious effect on the environment. Mostly over the centuries, the corruption has been replaced with cleaner, newer growth. But not entirely...

Gaskarfells was founded on the site, later, mostly so that the fellshard could be mined. Because of it's magical nature, veiled due to its matrixed mixing with native rock, the fellshard is safe (mostly) to handle and very useful for the creation of magical items. A guild of magical artificers effectively runs Gaskarfells, although few of them are actual sorcerers and warlocks; Gaskarfells is the foremost place in the Three Realms for the propagation of pseudomagery. Although the town has gradually grown to a modest yet successful size, due to lack of resources (and personnel) in the early days of its founding as well as early concerns about the safety of handling the fellshard ore, the Guildmasters took up some limited necromancy to create both workers and security for the town. This has remained in place even to this day, and skeleton and zombie workers and guards are a common sight in the streets of Gaskarfells. Most of the citizens of the town are quite used to them, and don't much notice them anymore, but visitors often find the grotesque and morbid sight of the walking dead accompanying Guildmembers about town, patrolling the wall, after curfew openly marching through the streets to be quite disturbing. In the mines themselves, they do most of the work. Although not "high powered" sapient or free-willed undead, like vampires or wights, there are probably several hundred skeletons and zombies. And, since it's Timischburg, there are probably some vampires somewhere in the power structure of the town. Although, as elsewhere in Timischburg, the vampires keep a low enough profile to maintain plausible deniability, and while most people believe in the "secret" vampire deep state, there are plenty of people with credible reasons for not believing that they exist too.

All citizens are issued numbered tokens that they wear on their clothing. This identifies them to the undead watch patrols, especially after curfew, as citizens and therefore they are left alone. Visitors must register at the gate when entering Gaskarfells, and they are issued temporary tokens for the duration of their stay as well. The Guildmembers are automatically exempt from being harassed by the undead, and the monsters will automatically obey Guildmembers. They wear, without exception when in public, a dark uniform of leather and dyed canvas, reinforced with dark iron, that is conducive to their magical crafting profession. They are also issued a leather overcoat, brimmed hat, and they usually keep their face partially covered. Over time, their exposure to low grade magical energy leaking from the fellshard ore will turn their skin slightly darker and leathery, as well as give them "Gaskarfells eyes"; the whites turn jet black, the irises shining silver-chrome, and the pupils change over time to resemble magical runes or symbols. While one can disguise oneself as a Guildmember, their real badge of office is their staff, with a glowing lump of fellshard ore fashioned into a knob at the top. 


In the center of town, which is in the center of the remains of the crater, is the Guildhouse, which in reality isn't a house at all, but rather an entire campus with living quarters for the Guildmembers and their most trusted retainers, workshops for the crafting to magical items utilizing fellshard ore, and research laboratories... as well as rich furnishings for the Guildmasters, conference rooms, and more. The security of the Guildhouse is famous, and few who are not members of the guild, or their pre-approved retainers, have ever been invited past its gates. The Guildhouse is rumored to extend deep beneath the surface, taking up space in what were once fellshard mines that are played out. Once they're finished, they are extended and turned into additional space for laboratories, offices, storage or secret experiments and more. Most of the rest of the town is in the rest of the crater, and the outer walls are around the crater rim. As the town has grown, some neighborhoods have started to sprout outside the walls, but this is a relatively new development.

While I do have some reasons for the PCs to travel to Gaskarfells during the Cult of Undeath campaign fronts, it is also a reasonable destination for those looking to get magical items direct from the source, especially if any of the characters are interested in pseudomagery. Alpon von Lechfeld had traveled their many times (although he isn't really a pseudomage) and after the Cult of Undeath campaign, Revecca uses her father's contacts and her fortune that she inherited from him to pursue the path of a pseudomage herself.



Wednesday, May 07, 2025

Reading goals

2023 was a pretty decent reading year; I kind of had to force myself back in the saddle after many years of poor reading and distractions by real life, computer games, and the internet. 2024 was not a good reading year. What with my relocation and vegging to YouTube and stuff after work most nights, I didn't do great. So far, I've determined to not watch stuff on YouTube unless I really want to, and I've limited most of my consumption to a few gaming lore videos, a few pop culture things here and there and hiking and overlanding videos. Consequently, it's still early May and I'm almost at my goal of 30 completed books for the year. I should easily hit my stretch goal of 40 and maybe even my "crazy goal" of 50 without too much trouble. For 2026, if I do get close to beating my "crazy goal" of 50 this year, I probably need to bump all of my goals up by ten—base minimum of thirty, actual goal of forty, stretch goal of fifty, and crazy goal of sixty.

Here's a screenshot of the current state of my reading tracker. 

The titles to the right are either on deck or in process. Gaming books at the top and novels below. These are in a constant state of flux as I change my mind on what to read and when, although I don't always update this file with what I think I might read next, because I'll probably get around to it eventually even if I defer it for a little while. Worse comes to worst, I can migrate them to the next year if I don't read them in the current year. The titles highlighted in yellow are pdf titles.



Elder Evils and Campaigns

I mentioned in my last post that I'm about to finish the Empire in Ruins Companion tonight; I've only got about 15 pages left to read. I'll probably also finish my re-read of Elder Evils tonight; I only have the Zargon chapter to re-read. They count as different categories because the Warhammer books that I have are pdfs and most of the 3e era books that I have (including that one) are actual physical books. I'm going through them fairly quickly, but I'm concerned that what I'm going to pick up next will be slower... although I'm undecided a bit on what I'm actually going to read next. I'm considering the strange idea of reading The Book of Vile Darkness (3e) as a physical book and The Book of Vile Darkness (4e) as a pdf, and reading the two of them concurrently to see how different they actually are. Other contenders on the physical book side are Fiendish Codex 1 (the one about the demons) which will be a quick read, I think, because it's a good, easy read, or Frostburn which may well be a slow slog, like Sandstorm was. I'm also thinking of adding Libris Mortis to the list in the short term. For physical game books, I also have 1) my recent printing of the B/X Omnibus to read, 2) Basic Fantasy RPG 4e, 3) Expedition to Castle Ravenloft, and 4) Heroes of Horror all on my short list, because I bought them recently. I've got a big stack of game pdfs to review, but the 5e Iron Kingdoms setting book is probably at the top of my short list, along with a few 4e books I've never read and some 3e Forgotten Realms stuff like Unapproachable East and Serpent Kingdoms. If I like the first one, I'll read that and maybe some others. But I'm still ambivalent on 3e FR or even FR in general, so I'm on the lookout for other books to target too.

Anyway, all that said, the Elder Evils. They're a weird bunch. Some of them qualify as Lovecraftian weird entities, but some of them don't exactly. The book itself, while fascinating, offers only the barest skeleton of an outline of how to use them in a campaign. Two of them actually have entire Adventure Paths written that follow the same concept, one of them so explicitly that they even mentioned it. Sertrous is the first of these, a snake-like obyrith lord who... really isn't an Elder Evil. He's an obyrith lord. Who's already been beaten twice... and who is dead. However, an aspect of him is still kicking around, who's the same CR as the demon lords from Fiendish Codex. Mechanically, that's kind of a mess. But realistically, the obyriths kind of overlap in conceptual genesis with the Far Realm entities and Elder Evils. I don't really like the concept of overthinking and overcategorizing big monsters in D&D. But it does mean that some of what it spends precious page space telling you is either irrelevant or incoherent. 


He's still kind of a cool entity, though. Kind of a Yig, except with an outline on how to actually consider using him. And then, a few years later, Paizo wrote the Serpent's Skull adventure path. It was the 7th actual adventure path released, and the third after Paizo switched over from 3.5 to Pathfinder, so it's not exactly compatible with the material in Elder Evils, but it's pretty close. Besides, they're also not exactly the same conceptually, so you'll have to mix and match elements to make it work. The biggest problem with the adventure path is that what's actually going on isn't foreshadowed very much, so it all starts going weird and sideways without much warning near the very end. This is where utilizing some Sertrous material would actually help improve the Serpent's Skull. And for that matter, Serpent's Skull, like all Paizo adventure paths, could use some pretty judicious pruning. I've actually done a big long review of the entire thing and how I'd use it at one point in the past. 

Serpent's Skull is much more of an Indiana Jones adventure than a horror story, though, so utilizing some Yig-stuff and Sertrous stuff and—of course—all of the rest of the things that I normally do to change the tone of my D&D-like campaigns needs to be done. The Sertrous chapter of Elder Evils actually helps in that regard... but some of its other ideas are a little less useful. Trying to make Sertrous correspond to the Hebrew word nachash or nagash and the whole serpent tempter from Adam and Eve was... I guess the rationale for why he's an elder evil and not just another obyrith lord, but I don't think it really works exactly and I'm sure I'd ignore it.

I wonder if anything at all useful from the FR 3e Serpent Kingdoms can be gleaned? I hope to see shortly.

Another chapter, which I earlier hadn't flagged as "one of my favorites" is the one on Kyuss, the Worm That Walks. This one is interesting, because although it's a pretty bare bones campaign outline, it also intersect with another bare bones campaign outline from Exemplars of Evil, and the two can be combined to make a much less bare-bones outline. It also references the Age of Worms adventure path, done by Paizo before they were "independent" and it's a specifically D&D campaign in the pages of Dungeon Magazine. That probably gives you way too much material to combine with the other two, but if you look at Age of Worms as a resource to loot rather than a campaign to be run exactly as written, you're really cooking with gas.

I also was much more kindly disposed towards "Father Llymic", a weird entity that I previously had thought was kind of silly, but which now I like. I mean, I don't like the illustration of him, but that's easy enough to reskin. Taking some ideas from this and maybe Rime of the Frost Maiden, Frostburn, and even Hoth from Star Wars: Old Republic I might be able to make a really cool Hyperborean snow and ice campaign or at least mini-campaign. It doesn't hurt that swtor has a dread seed on Hoth with all its weird corruption. And while I earlier had not really grokked the Zargon chapter, realizing or remembering that he's the same dude from the old B4 The Lost City adventure makes me kind of get why he was interesting a little more; although I don't think the write-up in Elder Evils itself is all that wonderful. I like the idea of kind of blending the Zargon stuff—with a better name; Zargon sounds like a stupid 80s b-movie character—with Robert E. Howard's "The Fire of Asshurbanipal" story.

In fact, I'm really considering writing up some short stories or novelettes with Dominic Clevenger and Kim Rugova poking around in Old Night sites, but using some of these Elder Evils as seeds for those stories. Fun times! I need to stop reading so much and do something more creative, though, to make that happen.

Deadliness in RPGs

Let's talk about OSR games vs "modern" D&D games, whatever exactly that means (it's worth noting that the OSR is itself ~twenty years old, depending on exactly when you consider it to have started, and 3e is often considered a "modern" D&D game, even though it's now at least two (again, depending on how you count) editions and twenty-five years old itself, and has been out of print for over fifteen years. The OSR could maybe have been considered to have started with the publication of Castles & Crusades in 2004, but certainly by 2006-7 as Basic Fantasy, OSRIC and later Labyrinth Lord and Swords & Wizardry were published, the OSR was in full gear. No wonder there's so much confusion as to what exactly the movement even is; it's aged quite a bit, and there are people who were just little kids when it started who are now participating in it. 

One oft-referred to perception is the lethality or deadliness of old school, and the supposed occurrence of PC death. Perception isn't always reality, so it's worth exploring a few points about this.


Professor Dungeon Master made an interesting video a few years ago about Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay, which has a reputation as a very deadly game, but he also pointed out that much of that reputation was based on the art and the tone of the text rather than on the reality of how deadly it actually was. In fact, he pointed out that B/X D&D was considerably deadlier in reality especially with Fate points and other get out of death free cards that Warhammer includes. Well... I'm not sure that there's any other such thing, other than some GM fiat in other games, but having just read the Enemy Within (Director's Cut) it's clear to me that there is at least some expectation that in in this campaigns there's character continuity. Warhammer FRPG was specifically designed to be a Call of Cthulhu in fantasy with urban investigation replacing dungeon-crawling, which was very passe in the British market in particular at the time it was published, so it is very trad style. 

But a lot of that perception of lethality in ye olden dayes could be how the games were actually played rather than anything inherent in the mechanics themselves. To some degree, early gamers, especially in the northern Midwest crowd of Arneson and Gygax, didn't particularly care about PC death, because roleplaying was a new innovation to their wargaming hobby, and they weren't really roleplaying all that much yet as we understand the concept now. Player characters were still mostly seen as game pieces in an unusual wargame where you ran a single character instead of an army or skirmish force of some kind. If your character died, well you rolled up a new one and tried again. No big deal. However, it didn't take too long for this to evolve. By the time Tom Moldvay wrote the Basic set, he said, for instance, "Sometimes I forget that [D&D] is a game and not a novel I’m reading or a movie I’m watching... A good [D&D] campaign is similar to the creation of a fantasy novel, written by the DM and the players as the adventure unfolds." The perception of the game as something other than an avant-garde spin on a wargame had set in, and it truly became a roleplaying game, at least for some groups. I'm quite sure that early gamers didn't really think too hard about lost characters, and it happened more frequently. At least, frequently relative to what came later. Not necessarily later as in "modern" rulesets, but later as in trad style gameplay, where people roleplayed their characters more, and that became the prevailing reason to play in the first place. 

I suspect that a lot of the expectations of lethality are overstated, or at least it wasn't the designers' intentions, except in some tournament or deliberately meatgrinder style modules. Many of them refer to the idea that the expectation is that the game was for a larger group than most people probably actually played in. Certainly, a module will be pretty lethal for a group of 3-5 characters if it was calibrated and designed for closer to ten.

I think once again, the OSR has taken an element that was more common in the past than it is now, taken it out of context and pinned it in opposition to "modern" games rather than to the rise of trad playstyle, which predated "modern" games by the better part of twenty years or more (depending on the group). They've also exaggerated the old school position to a caricature of what it once was in a some games and declared that this caricature is The Way Things Were and The Way Things Ought to Be™. 

It is, of course, the neo-trad style that is closer to what OSRians think "modern" games are like; the online Sims-like power-fantasy where you just noodle around with a character that's an idealized personified avatar of the player, and they don't even want to be challenged, just to experience the setting like a tourist. I've had characters die, or at least seen them, in modern games. I'm not a huge fan of plentiful character death, because I am, after all, a trad-style player who likes the whole experience to resemble a novel, like Tom Moldvay said in the intro pages of Basic, but I am old-fashioned even when I reject the precepts of "old school", and the risk of death is still important. I am, after all, also a fan of the Call of Cthulhu play paradigm. (Which also isn't as lethal as its reputation, I don't believe, but y'know. It's still considerably moreso than D&D of any version.) But as a trad player who utilizes what is, essentially, a rules-lite extreme derivation of 3e, a "modern" game, I find the neo-trad position to be just as radical and unlike what I want as the OSRians do.

I'm not sure how prevalent that style really is anyhow, or how closely tied to 5e it really is. The OSR's perception of this vast gulf of expectation between modern and old school here was, I think, pretty overstated.

As an aside, jumping back to the Warhammer reference above, I just finished reading the Enemy Within Director's Cut, including the Companion books. I have literally about 10-15 pages left in the last book, which I'll finish tonight. It's hard to take it seriously as a grim and gritty setting when they're so woke. They've obviously swapped what were originally a lot of male NPCs for female ones, who are supposed to be just as big, tough and masculine as the males. But they were a little sloppy sometimes in their editing, and occasionally the original name or pronouns will still poke through. I would never consider limiting PC choice by sex, or penalizing players for wanting to play a girl, but let's be real; women are not men, and it is really off-putting to see them treated as if they were. Just a few months ago, we had the fiasco of Olympic boxing where some men dressed like women swept the awards and actually seriously injured a few women boxers. Women are neither psychologically nor physically equivalent to men. And like I said; PCs are PCs; they're always special anyway, but if treating men and women as equivalent is prevalent throughout the setting, it seriously undermines its ability to be taken seriously. This is especially important for a setting like Warhammer which is meant to be grim, mostly serious (barring the puns) and as much of a horror/Cthulhu like setting as it is a fantasy/Tolkien like setting.

Tuesday, May 06, 2025

Reddit is almost as bad as ENWorld

As the title says. I need to get out of internet conversations altogether. I rarely find that people are 1) intelligent enough to follow the logical outcome of what they even say, 2) discuss in good faith, or 3) exhibit anything at all approaching common sense. In fact, as both reddit and ENWorld have become more and more liberal, they are subject to the following problem, which rather than quote in part, I'll just link to. It's a very good piece.

https://barsoom.substack.com/p/the-involution-of-the-liberal-mind

Anyway, today's particular nonsense came from a post in, I believe r/osr where someone asked what changes to ShadowDark one would make. Houserules, etc. There was a small digression where one guy said that he strongly recommended not changing anything until the OP had played with the rules as is first, and a couple of other people chimed in to suggest that was some kind of law or something. Now, at the bottom of this page, you may notice that one of my mottos is, in part, the famous Latin phrase "Eventus stultorum magister est." And the fact that I first heard it in Tombstone doesn't negate the wisdom of this ancient proverb. That advice given on reddit is lowest common denominator advice, literally for the fools—the stulti, who can't figure anything out except by experiencing it personally. It's ridiculous advice for anyone who's been a roleplaying hobbyist for any amount of time at all. But, I guess, if you're not smart enough to extrapolate how a rule will work in play or if you're even interested in using that particular rule, I guess maybe it's decent advice. Stumble around on your own the hard way if that's the only way you can learn. Sucks to be you.

This was especially notable given the example I gave. One of the things that I don't care for in ShadowDark is carousing, wherein you can spend treasure to get bonus XP. I don't like any GP = XP equivalency rules, or rules where you can trade one for the other. There's generally two reasons for this kind of rule; 1) to motivate people to go seek out after treasure (I have no interest in motivating players to do that, but Gary Gygax did, back when the game was much more wargamey and roleplaying hadn't yet really caught on as the actual main event of the hobby, because everyone doing it was an old wargamer.) 2) to bleeds off excess treasure, because now your characters have too much. I called it a patch, in fact, to bleed off excess treasure, because due to inertia from old school treasure distribution, which has for a variety of reasons never been addressed in D&D-likes, characters get too much for most GM's taste. 

Given that this situation has literally been the case in D&D-likes for more than 50 years now, the idea that I don't know if I like how it works specifically in ShadowDark is absurd. 

And then Kelsey Dionne, writer of ShadowDark jumped in and said that carousing wasn't a patch to fix excess treasure, it was a resource to be spent. That's semantics, though. If you have treasure to spend on bonus XP, especially the really spendy bonuses, then you have too much treasure, and the bonus XP is a method to bleed off that treasure. And advance faster. Both of which are, by my tastes, not desirable. Therefore, they're easily fixed by simply giving less treasure and getting rid of the carousing stuff altogether. Don't bleed treasure (that you now don't have anyway) off to advance faster, so that you have a slower advancement schedule—which is also better. 

And... just to add some visual interest, here's another piece of Midkemia cover art, from the book that follows the Riftwar Saga and kind of starts treating with the next generation; Arutha and Anita's spoiled twin sons.

I have to wonder if the artist, Don Maitz, is familiar with Arnold Friberg's famous Book of Mormon illustrations, given the obvious resemblance here to this earlier work. His biography doesn't mention anything about his religious affiliation, or even much at all about his personal life, other than that he's married to Janny Wurts, who co-wrote the Empire trilogy with Feist, a spin-off from the Riftwar Saga. Probably how he got the gig in the first place. Of course, you don't need to be LDS to appreciate the art of Arnold Friberg; I've often thought that any sword & sorcery fan would immediately click with his weird mixture of savage Mesoamerican, Middle Eastern and Roman style aesthetic. 

Speaking of OSR weirdness, here's another reddit post I made, on a thread on "what are your OSR 'sins'?"

The thread title hardly endears to those who already see the OSR as almost cult-like in it's application of the "correct" way to play. That said, I'm a fan of the OSR mostly because I'm old, I remember when OD&D, Holmes, and B/X were what we played because they were current, and I love the DIY, garage band, indie aesthetic that the OSR has brought back to D&D-like games. I'm not, however:

  • Very interested in faithful recreations of the original rules that don't fix certain things for either mechanical improvement or to change the tone of the game. I greatly dislike the overly weak thief, even though I love the archetype, I greatly dislike Vancian magic, I disbelieve the illusion that the cleric is actually an archetype and I don't like using them, etc. I've also never had problems with a shorter skill system of some kind, having also played plenty of GURPS and Cthulhu back in the day and been very comfortable with the idea of skills, etc.
  • I'm also not at all interested in the so-called OSR playstyle. I don't have "adventurers" as a social class of any kind, nor do I find the implied story of dungeon-crawling for treasure to be interesting in the least. I strongly dislike dungeons, especially if they're loaded with gotcha traps, puzzles, riddles, or other things that have never existed really in reality. My playstyle is quite trad, although modified with a number of old-fashioned caveats. Maybe paleo-trad. My games tend to resemble more a combination of The Godfather, Mission: Impossible and James Bond in a dark Warhammer FRP or Cthulhu-like fantasy setting, and my motto is that while maybe I'm not old school, I certainly am old fashioned. That said, I don't mind hex-crawling as much as dungeon-crawling, but maybe that's because hiking/backpacking is another real-life hobby of mine.
  • I simply cannot wrap my head around the idea that games that adhere to the "OSR as playstyle" but which don't really resemble old D&D are actually OSR. I know that I'm going to gradually lose this argument more and more as time goes on, but I've got to give credit to Yochai Gal for trying really hard to get the NSR recognized as something separate from, albeit related to, the OSR, rather than part of the OSR as a whole. Part of his failure may well have been the toxic gatekeeping, purity testing and insane overly political stance of the NSR in general, which makes it more difficult to focus on the NSR as an actual category of game and playstyle that's separate from the OSR. Or maybe the different types of rules aren't as important as I think that they are, and the OSR and the NSR, from the point of view of someone outside of either, are too similar to bother splitting.
  • Similarly, I'm a little ambivalent on some aspects of weirdness and gonzo. While I incorporate a great deal of Lovecraftian influence in my fantasy gaming, it's less of the cosmic horror and semi-science fiction elements, and more of the interdimensional horror and risk of character madness. Warhammer FRP and the Darkest Dungeons video games are more the style that I'm looking at rather that mi-go and Yithians taking people to their interplanetary cities or whatever. Demons are, in fact, demons, and not intergalactic aliens, or whatever. I also dislike science fiction elements in fantasy; or rather, I don't consider it fantasy anymore when they're present, and I prefer to keep them discrete. Don't get me wrong; a Thundarr the Barbarian meets Cthulhupunk sounds amazing, but I'd have to treat it like something completely separate from whatever I'm doing in fantasy. Probably another reason that I consider the NSR so different from the OSR, given that the NSR is "more weird" than the otherwise fairly traditional OSR.

This isn't part of my post, but while I'm giving credit to Gal for that particular attempt, I also credit (blame) mostly him specifically for the NSR being such a hotbed of woke politics and cancel culture nonsense. He's specifically the one most responsible for how toxic the NSR community is. Although maybe it was inevitable given the genesis of the NSR community in the early work of weirdos like James Raggi and Zac S. to begin with. It naturally gravitated to that kind of personality, even if the games themselves (some of them, anyway) aren't necessarily woke. Some of them, in fact, I'd actually probably like. But the community... blegh.

Maybe, given that the OSR has been around for a good twenty years now (depending on when exactly you consider it to have started.) I have to stop trying to think of it as a monolithic thing. There are a lot of people in the OSR doing a lot of different (and mutually exclusive) things. It's OK to be a fan of certain elements of it and not necessarily the movement as a whole. I think a lot of people are having trouble letting go of the idea that they're part of "the OSR community" but I do think that it's clear that original B/X fans and fans of NSR stuff are two different communities... at the very least. In reality, you can break it down into being fans of all kinds of specific games and not of others; just like being fans of RPGs overall. The OSR has become something too big to just treat it as a single thing, just like being "a gamer" is too big for that mostly too.

Doesn't mean that there can't be a lot of overlap between fans of various different games or even various broader approaches to gaming, however, even while acknowledging that being a fan of this or that isn't necessarily correlated with being a fan of that or this. That's a bit of a pet peeve of mine in general; the assumption that because I play D&D, I must like any other RPG, or that I must like anime (I don't) or heavy metal (also don't.) But because the OSR was for quite some time united under a relatively singular approach and goals, it's been harder to give up the idea that it's not anymore.

Monday, May 05, 2025

Magician by Raymond Feist

One of my all-time favorite epic fantasies that isn't Tolkien has always been Feist's Riftwar Saga. I've always seen it published in four volumes: Magician: Apprentice, Magician: Master, Silverthorn and A Darkness at Sethanon. Each varies in length from about 325 printed pages to ~430 printed pages, probably averaging a little north of 350. The size a typical fantasy novel would be in the 80s and 90s before Robert Jordan starting writing books that crept up to and eventually passed 1,000 pages in length. But the two volumes of Magician were actually originally published as a single volume, and it somehow was about 550 or so pages. Must have been smaller type. I guess the market wasn't quite ready for that.


I just finished, recently, re-reading the two Magician books. I originally bought the 1980s versions, before the "director's cut" became the only kind you could get (although the cover art I've attached is from said "director's cuts". I've actually always preferred them; when I first read the director's cuts, after my original copies got lost in someone else's move and he accidentally took them with him, I thought some of the added text, cut and expanded scenes that had been restored, etc. actually felt kind of clunky and I preferred the "original" edited version. But that's really neither here nor there; the differences aren't really all that big. I got on used marketplaces to replace my copies with the same printing that I'd originally had, so I read the edited 80s version of the book. A few things come to mind:

  • It's certainly epic in scope, with one of the main point of view, in fact the main point of view character becoming a powerful magic-user who can toss around spells that make him a fantasy superhero of sorts. As well, the cross-dimensional war waged between Midkemia; a fairly typical D&D-ish or Tolkienish fantasy world and Kelewan, which was belatedly admitted to have been Tekumel of the Empire of the Petal Throne product with the serial numbers slightly sanded off being a perfect example of the epic scope. 
  • That said, few major characters are non-human; there's a handful of D&D-like elves and dwarfs, but they are also minor supporting characters. The Saga is remarkably humano-centric by today's standards, and remarkably traditional in most respects by today's standards too. Probably a big part of the reason that I like it, of course.
  • In addition to the prevalence of normal human characters, as opposed to magic-users or other magical characters of any type, the story is surprisingly swashbucklery. Much of it, especially with regards to the plot-lines that follow characters like Arutha, one of the main point of view characters, or later, Martin Longbow, etc. would not feel very out of place in a historical fiction swashbuckling adventure as written by Rafael Sabatini or someone like that. Ivanhoe and The Black Arrow were deliberately written to reflect a more Medieval language in style, but otherwise are very good swashbucklers, whereas Sabatini's works usually take place a bit later. But still, the similarities were striking to me. Reminded me again of why I like the kinds of games that I do, rather than "dungeon-crawls." Even High Fantasy, to say nothing of more sword & sorcery style stories, benefit from being more swashbucklery adventure rather than the bizarre story of D&D. Sneaking around doing intrigue in Krondor, or the military stuff is very traditional, and not overtly fantastic at all. The fantasy stands out more for being more restrained.
  • It's well done in the sense that it doesn't overdo POV characters, a major problem for some of the epic fantasies that have come more recently. Other than a handful of moments with Martin, Macros or a few others for some very specific scenes, if I remember correctly, we get Pug, Tomas and Arutha as point of view characters, and they're the only ones that really count. In the next two volumes, we add Jimmy the Hand and maybe a scene or two with Locky. That's it. There's really no reason to have much more than that. This is a big epic fantasy, four volumes long, and while they're shorter than some of today's fantasies, Feist himself estimates that all of the volumes in the entire larger Riftwar Cycle (not Saga, which are just the first four books) is about 135,000 words. That's still plenty of words. In fact, I still find after all these years that that's about the ideal size for a fantasy novel. 
  • Magician, if it were a single volume, which it's not in my printing but which it was previously, stands alone. Sure, sure; it was later expanded into the "Riftwar Saga" and while I like the next two volumes a lot, Magician was obviously written without necessarily any reference to them. It ends on a satisfying conclusion, and if you just stopped there, it'd be sufficient.
I've also read, many years ago, the Empire trilogy set on Kelewan and co-written (I've always wondered exactly what that means) by Janny Wurts, and the two-book Krondor's Sons series, which are really two separate one-shots. When I tried to read the first book of the next part of the saga, the Serpentwar Saga, I couldn't get into it for whatever reason. None of the characters or locations were familiar, and I was busy with a young family and grad school at the time, and I just stopped there. But considering how much I like the original Riftwar Saga, I've always kind of been tempted to try again. Sadly, my public library doesn't seem to have any of these titles anymore. At the time, they were relatively newly published, but now they've been out for decades. But I'm thinking about gradually acquiring them on the used market and, well, trying again.

It's a free country (spoiler alert; no it isn't)

The Z-man's post, slightly edited by me. The short answer is that we do NOT live in a free country, and haven't for a long time.

The story of Shiloh Hendrix has brought to the surface things that have been bubbling under the surface for some time. The most obvious is the general fatigue with regards to race among white people. The media is doing the usual point and shriek, expecting the lynch mob to chase after this woman, but instead money is flowing into her fundraising account with messages of support. The white population is using this event to make a point about race in America.

For most white people, this is not a moral issue. It is a practical issue. They wonder why we have Somalis in Minnesota. No one campaigned on bringing tribes of Somalis into the country and dumping them into white communities. No one was organizing pressure groups demanding the importation of Somalis. The people who made this decision never mentioned it to the public and the public was never consulted. Suddenly, we have this new problem, and we are expected to adjust to it.

If you are white, a central part of your life is navigating around nonwhites. Maybe it is knowing where the black areas are, so you avoid crime. Maybe it is teaching your children about dealing with the nons in their school, so they do not get jammed up by the morality police. Maybe it is educating the old people in your life on how to spot Indian scammers. Of course, the background noise of the public square is the endless drone of race talk.

The question is how did it get to this? Like the Somalis in Minnesota, the public was never asked about any of this. The people who decided on the new rules never campaigned on them or asked for public support. They just did it. They kept doing it one court case, one new law at a time. The place to start is the landmark Supreme Court decision Shelley v. Kramer, where the court declared that restrictive covenants violated the 14th Amendment.

In 1945, a black couple named J.D. and Ethel Shelley attempted to purchase a home in a white neighborhood in St. Louis, Missouri. The property was subject to a restrictive covenant that prohibited nonwhites from occupying the property. This was a deliberate setup to get another case in the system on this matter. McGhee v. Sipes was a similar case out of Michigan. This is a common trick by the usual suspects to help fast track a case to the Supreme Court.

Of course, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the blacks, declaring that while restrictive covenants do not violate the rights of the parties to the contract, any enforcement of these covenants violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. In other words, homeowners are free to make any rules they like about who can live in their community, but no court will enforce those rights if they discriminate on race.

What the court did is shift from a position where it enforces private contracts to a position where it decides if the contract is acceptable. In one decision we went from a world where private parties were free to make contracts with one another for whatever reasons they liked to a world where private parties must seek permission from the state before entering into a contract. If the court could selectively enforce contracts, as in the Shelley case, then they could do it with every type of contract.

This marked the beginning of the general shift away from a rights-based society where the state is a neutral arbiter in disputes between citizens to a permission-based society in which the state regulates the behavior of citizens to achieve goals never imagined or considered in the Constitution. Ten years after Shelley, the Court sealed the deal with the Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka decision, where they enshrined this entirely new moral paradigm into law.

Brown took the basic concept of Shelley, where the courts get to decide which contracts to enforce, and extended it to the law. Specifically, they declared that any law or private action that discriminates is assumed to be unconstitutional. Any law or behavior that furthers an open and inclusive society is assumed to be constitutional. This has been the moral framework of race communism ever since. The reason Shiloh Hendrix is famous now is because of this moral framework.

The great frustration that white people sense in that clip of Ms. Hendrix using colorful euphemisms is the result of the American false consciousness. We are regularly told we live in a rights-based society, that we are free to live our lives as we see fit, but in reality, we live in a permission-based society. If anything you do or say is deemed to be discriminatory by the courts or someone empowered by the courts, you can find yourself in a jungle of moral contradictions.

It is a good example of how reform within the rules is probably impossible. To fix the race issue it would require tearing down this moral edifice erected by the courts that now dominates the old Constitutional arrangement. That means removing the moral authority of the courts entirely. To do that would require a revolution in the law where lawyers cease to be a secular clerisy. Such a revolution in the law will require a revolution in the streets.

That aside, the tension between how we want to act and how we are told to act is why Ms. Hendrix blew her top in the park. She does not want to live in a world where she and her children are harassed by Africans. She thinks she has the right to not be harassed by Africans. She does not live in that world as the people in charge think she should be harassed by Africans. That video exists because we are about to find out who shall overcome whom.

Friday, May 02, 2025

Forgotten Realms (3e)

I've been reading a lot lately, and actually not as much the roleplaying game books as normal. I picked up and polished off very quickly Magician: Apprentice, which I'm not surprised by; I've read that before a few times and knew that I liked it. I needed to read it again. I already pivoted into Magician: Master, the sequel, and am making good headway. I've also read quite a bit from my Flame Tree printing of Epic Tales: Greek Myths & Tales, which I consider a non-fiction book. When I'm done with that, I've also got the Norse and Celtic (i.e., Irish, I think, although maybe there's some Welsh in there too) versions of those same books. I've got two gamebooks in my backpack, Elder Evils and the Lulu.com printing of the Moldvay Basic and Cook/Marsh Expert put together into a single volume. But I also finished, a few days ago, my pdf book, which is almost always going to be an RPG book too, because those are mostly the books that I have on pdf. In this case, it was the 3e Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting. 

You can't play D&D and not know about Forgotten Realms, of course. It's been (I believe) the most popular setting in the game for many, many years, and it's the default setting of 5e in the way that Greyhawk was for 3e or Mystara was for the "basic" D&D line for many years. Although in all three cases, the actual setting material wasn't really all that good. FR got it's original release as the so-called "gray box" kind of late in the 1e period, it got a second and different 2e boxed set, and then, of course, got a big 3e campaign setting book, which is often considered the gold standard of campaign settings. 4e also had pretty extensive FR books, as I recall, although they weren't as well received because by default, they had to change a ton of stuff about the setting. 

I've been familiar with FR since, oh, the early 90s at least. I actually quite like the original Salvatore "Halfling Gem" trilogy of novels, and the Dark Elf prequel trilogy that he wrote after that, although the handful of additional volumes that I've read in that ongoing saga had gradually lost me. Sometimes when stories are done, they should stay done and not be revisited just because they were popular, and that one certainly qualifies (I actually think that's true for the Riftwar Saga too, which I mentioned re-reading. I struggled to get very far into the post Riftwar Saga additional Riftwar Cycle books.) But I've never read the 3e setting all the way through, nor have I read any of the other setting books for it. Since the 3e one is considered the gold standard, and because I bought a pdf of it many years ago. But because I kinda knew what it was about, read about it online and in Dragon and Dungeon magazine, etc. I had predisposed prejudices about what FR was. I figured it was time to find out once and for all if it was true.

Before I get to that, though, let me preface this with some context. My reading of the Greek Myths, which of course, I'm already pretty familiar with; Greek mythological cycles mainly focus, after describing who all of the Gods are and what their deal is, with about half a dozen major story cycles based on (in most cases) a singular hero: Perseus, Theseus, Herakles, Jason (and the Argonauts, but we'll get to them in a moment) the Trojan War, especially with regards to Achilles, and the Odyssey of Odysseus. All of these are super-hero power fantasies. Almost all of these characters are literally demigods; part divine, and superlative examples of what the Greeks imagined a hero to be, with literal superpowers. The Argonauts were a whole crew of superheroes, led by Jason, the wisest of them all. It even has two superheroes with wings, who chase away the harpies from the Argo by flying after them like Angel from the X-men. If you look beyond the Greeks, this was pretty common for most of these old mythological tales. The Norse actually had more stories about the gods themselves rather than about heroes, but Sigurd qualifies as a Hercules-like Germanic figure, and among the Irish, Cu Chalainn is also a demigod and a superhero. Older stuff fits this pattern as well, if you read about Gilgamesh, the Sumerian superhero, for instance. 

In general, the Germanic and to a lesser extent the Celtic people told more stories about regular people, though. The Sagas, those that weren't simply historical, were about people who were mostly just normal people. And the literature of heroes who were heroes but not superheroes with superpowers is a factor of the peoples of Northern Europe who make up one of the three pillars of Western Civilization. 

Much of the founding literature of the fantasy genre as we know it is also relatively low-key in this respect compared to the mythological stuff that they were building off of. The Matters of France (Roland and Charlemagne) and of Britain (Arthurian tales) relative to the Matter of Rome (Classical mythology), which is more proximate to the fantasy genre as we know it, and although Lancelot or Roland were, of course, pretty superlative heroes themselves, they weren't overtly superheroic like Perseus or Gilgamesh. And as fantasy emerged, via Tolkien, Eddison, Morris, and the sword & sorcery crew; Howard, Leiber, etc. this more grounded approach with heroic yet (mostly) realistic characters in more grounded yet still fantastic settings became the hallmark of the genre.

That context established, Forgotten Realms had a reputation of very powerful; overly powerful, in fact, characters marching like legends across the landscape. But not necessarily in a mythic sense; more in a kind of cringy power-fantasy kind of way. Superheroes that did nothing heroic at all, but which were powerful enough to do whatever they wanted to do. Supervillains in the worst cases, who were only considered good by fiat and default rather than because of their actions. Entitled, bratty little princesses (regardless of sex) who succeeded by fiat and deus ex machina rather than their actual merits. 

I found that maybe in that was a little bit of an overblown complaint, but not entirely without merit. There are a lot of slightly cringy overpowered power-fantasy NPCs running around. But they mostly just seem like high level D&D characters. Higher level than they needed to be, and higher level than any other D&D NPCs (up to that point) had been, however. 

There was also a vibe of low-status male pining; a kind of gamma perspective that pervades at an almost ambient level to the setting. Signature characters like Elminster are not only over-powered in terms of rules, but they get lots of inexplicable attention from high powered girls throughout the setting. They like to sit around impressing themselves with their cleverness while they deliver often rather silly and cringy lectures to the reader. To be fair, this can easily be ignored, and the setting can be treated simply as if it were a regular D&D setting, and the tone of the material at your table can be different. There are some cool ideas within the setting, like the Red Wizards of Thay. The Dalelands maybe aren't exactly exciting or unique, but they're fine as a settling element, as are many of the Western Heartlands areas of the northern Sword Coast, including even Waterdeep, Baldur's Gate, etc. It's useable, if not exciting, stuff. 

In fact, there was almost too much of an emphasis on useability, at least with this version of the setting. It started to strain credibility that there are so many monsters just hanging around, that "adventurers" is such an important economic, political and social force in the setting, that there's "dungeons" all over the place, etc. 

I suspect that for people who like Forgotten Realms, this is a big part of what they do like, but I'll say that in general, my perspective after this deep dive, reading the entire 320 or so page small text campaign setting 3e book, that I'm not very interested in it. I didn't think that I was, and I hadn't been interested for many years (this book is more than twenty years old, after all—and it's not exactly the first version of the setting either). I found that it was much as I expected it to be. It comes across as a "cozy" fantasy setting for over-the-top power and fame fantasies for Mary Sue characters that's heavily invested in D&D mechanics specifically, written by a bunch of northern liberals; Canadian and PNW in origin, who are hapless gammas on the socio-sexual hierarchy. It's somewhat toned down by the need to be more appealing to a mass market, but ultimately, that ambiance can't help but poke through.

That said, Ed Greenwood, a person about whom I've heard a number of personal communication creepy and cringy anecdotes, claims that his own version of the setting in his own home game and written notes is quite a bit darker than any published, and has a different tone. And even people who've read multiple versions of the setting over the years claim that the original is the best in some respects, or at least the darkest and most open. OSR types like it, FR-heads probably prefer 3e. Maybe I'll try and add that to my reading list for this year, although it won't be near the top of the list. 

I also found that the organization and focus on a lot of mechanics, especially up front, was quite the slog, but I don't know that I can blame this particular book or this particular setting for that, as that was common for most 3e setting books, even third party ones. Eberron had much of that same problem, as did Rokugan and others. In good consciousness, I can't exactly recommend the book. I doubt I'll ever read it again, now that I have, and I'm really glad that I didn't spring for a POD version, or overpriced used market copies (tend to go for $75-80 or so.) The pdf is on drivethrurpg for $15, which is already plenty. But I don't regret having recently re-read the Halfling Gem trilogy, and as soon as I find where I put it when I relocated, I'll re-read my omnibus Dark Elf prequel trilogy, again, without guilt. The setting's not a disaster. But it's not my cup of tea, and having dug into what is often considered the gold standard of setting books, and the gold standard in particular of Forgotten Realms (along with the gray box) I'm confident that I don't care to ever really use it.

It's worth noting that many of the issues that I have with the Forgotten Realms, while not necessarily endemic to the 5e Realms, as I understand it, have become commonplace in D&D overall. We have settings that are—literally—designed to mimic Hogwarts, except in D&D. As Professor Dungeon Master says, 5e is like The Muppet Show. It's heavily invested in the trope of power fantasies of gammas who don't even want to go adventure as much as they want to roleplaying flirting with monsters, or just hanging around in a fantasy DisneyWorld, except even more Disney than DisneyWorld. I've had little interest in 5e, even as I'm now playing in a longish campaign of it (which we're only 20-25% done with, for what it's worth). It's OK. But it's not what I would choose either from a system standpoint, or from a setting standpoint.